Gary Mayor Speaks on Brewer Death Probe

Gary Mayor Eddie Melton addressed the ongoing investigation into the death of Nicole Mabon-Brewer on Wednesday, explaining why the city is keeping a distance from the case. The family of the deceased believes her husband, former Gary City Councilman Ron Brewer, may have played a role in her death.

Mabon-Brewer, 47, was found shot to death inside her Gary home on September 3, 2025. Her death is currently classified as undetermined, and no criminal charges have been filed in connection with the incident. The case remains open as authorities review the findings.

In a statement released Wednesday, Melton stated that the city made a deliberate choice to stay separate from the investigation to avoid any actual or perceived conflict of interest. He noted that the city supported the appointment of a special prosecutor. Following that appointment, the Lake County Prosecutor's Office requested that the Indiana State Police take over the investigation. The Gary Police Department agreed to that arrangement.

Melton said the matter deserves an independent, thorough, and transparent investigation without interference from the city. He also acknowledged the personal connection to the case, noting that he knew Mabon-Brewer during their high school years. The mayor offered condolences to her family and friends, stating that they deserve answers.

The daughter and father of Mabon-Brewer have raised serious allegations against Ron Brewer. They said Nicole had warned them years earlier that he threatened to kill her and make the death appear to be a suicide. The family also questioned whether Brewer's alleged connections to the Gary Police Department affected how the case was handled.

Indiana State Police previously told FOX Chicago that its investigation had been completed and submitted to the special prosecutor for review. Melton said the city will defer all questions about the investigation to the Indiana State Police and the Lake County Prosecutor's Office.